If you've read my review of the Aerostich, you're probably surprised that I own a leather jacket. Well I am too and I haven't made a decision as to which I really prefer.
On a purely objective level the Stich wins. Easy care, don't have to worry if it gets wet, tons of pockets, and features galore. But there's something about leather - I feel different when I have the Avenger on. To make matters even more confusing I still wear the Stich pants when I wear the Avenger jacket.
I haven't broken down and bought leather pants for a couple of reasons. I haven't found an inexpensive pair I like or that fit, and the pants that did fit (Vanson PTSR) cost more than I paid for the jacket. I can't reconcile that fact in my mind.
I got the jacket from Newenough for over a $100 less than the cost of a new Avenger. They sell new and used Vanson, as well as other brand, leathers. Nice people to deal with. The jacket was in mint condition and other than being broken in it was indistinguishable from a new jacket. If and when they get a pair of used PTSR pants I'll probably splurge for them.
The Avenger has 2 large panels that zip open to reveal perforated leather. With the panels open the jacket is quite breezy and comfortable even on a 90+ degree day. Close the panels and you have a cool weather jacket. The best of both worlds.
The jacket is solidly constructed with very thick leather, pockets for back, shoulder and elbow/forearm amour options and the attention to detail that are the hallmarks of Vanson leathers. You'd be proud to own this jacket and for an all weather leather jacket it probably can't be beat.
If I have one complaint about this jacket it is its almost total lack of pockets. All you get are two small zippered pocket on the inside of the jacket. After the stich this is a real shock. I'm guessing the Vanson people don't think you should have a jacket full of keys, Swiss army knives, leathermans, what have you, in the event of a crash. Probably sound thinking, but I still miss the pockets. I'd really like a small pocket on the forearm, like the stich, to put my motorcycle key in when not riding.